Skip to content

Complete Cycle 5 Stage 6 infrastructure plan and resolve traitmech-infra-0007 (#2002) - #2029

Merged
realmarcin merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
c5s6-infrastructure
Oct 26, 2026
Merged

realmarcin merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
c5s6-infrastructure

Conversation

@realmarcin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Completes Cycle 5 Stage 6 (infrastructure) of mech-goal-sequence-20261019:

@realmarcin

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Independent Adversarial Review Report — PR #2029 (c5s6-infrastructure -> main)

  • Run / Cycle / Stage: mech-goal-sequence-20261019, Cycle 5, Stage 6 (infrastructure), Revision 1
  • Branch / HEAD Commit: c5s6-infrastructure (4fe2f69b4dad3c5966e37e5e127359b2cfbd0de2, synced with origin/c5s6-infrastructure)
  • Base Commit (main): bc1dfa795cce63059bc4744d06aa371aa335e423
  • Disposition: approved

1. File-by-File Inspection (git diff main...c5s6-infrastructure, 10 files changed)

  1. INFRA_TASKS.md:
    • Reconciles traitmech-infra-0007 from status: open to status: resolved in both the machine-readable YAML inventory block and the narrative section, recording its Cycle 5 Stage 6 resolution and verification summary.
    • Retains all 6 previously resolved tasks (traitmech-infra-0001 through traitmech-infra-0006) without modification.
  2. reviews/workflow/latest.yaml:
    • Appends the verified closure entry for Cycle 5 Stage 5 (reviews/workflow/mech-goal-sequence-20261019/cycle-000005/stage-05/revision-0001/evidence.yaml, sha256: 863188fa4de55a257b4d586894822e279ce719d30a3cc416bcbe5d456ac9f618, receipt_sha256: ae17a10a151b8e3e27350a72ffb7cf95127f21f8c4cc3599292a9e431c04fd63, PR curate(stage5): resolve Cycle 5 Stage 4 definition_source review findings (#2002) #2026, head_sha: 512d3e60b778d74f99444750c37770ce4305206e, merge_commit_sha: bc1dfa795cce63059bc4744d06aa371aa335e423, merged_at: '2026-10-25T23:04:50Z', verified_at: '2026-10-25T23:20:12.270467+00:00', all 8 CI checks passing).
  3. scripts/audit_evidence_snippets.py:
    • Adds MIN_CORPUS_QUOTE_CHARS = 16.
    • Tracks corpus_quoted_refs_16: set[str] = set() in the first pass of audit() for references carrying a non-elliptical snippet of length >= 16 on non-OBJECT_PROPERTY records when check_definition_sources=True.
    • Computes def_source_in_ev = def_source in record_any_refs and has_corpus_16_quote = (not is_object_property and def_source_in_ev and def_source in corpus_quoted_refs_16) in the second pass of audit(), flagging UNQUOTED_DEFINITION_SOURCE when def_source.startswith(("PMID:", "DOI:")) and (def_source in family_quoted or has_corpus_16_quote) and def_source not in record_refs.
  4. tests/test_audit_evidence_snippets.py:
    • Adds test_unquoted_definition_source_corpus_wide_16char_quote_when_in_evidence, exercising all relevant branches:
      1. Cross-cohort < 16-char quote ("pH homeostasis", 14 chars) does not trigger corpus-wide propagation;
      2. Cross-cohort >= 16-char non-elliptical quote on a CLASS record triggers UNQUOTED_DEFINITION_SOURCE on a CLASS record that cites definition_source in evidence[].reference without a snippet (def_source_in_ev == True);
      3. Unrelated CLASS record that does not cite definition_source in evidence[].reference (def_source_in_ev == False) is not flagged by distant corpus-wide quotes;
      4. Adding a verbatim snippet to the record clears the finding.
  5. history/infrastructure/stage6_infrastructure_plan/2026-10-25T233000Z-antigravity-c5s601.yaml:
  6. reviews/workflow/mech-goal-sequence-20261019/cycle-000005/stage-06/revision-0001/infra_snapshot.md:
    • Exact byte-for-byte snapshot of main:INFRA_TASKS.md at bc1dfa795cce63059bc4744d06aa371aa335e423.
  7. reviews/workflow/mech-goal-sequence-20261019/cycle-000005/stage-06/revision-0001/implementation_plan.md:
    • Documents the frozen intake scope, cutoff timestamp, SHA-256 digest, 7-task inventory table, dependency-aware plan for traitmech-infra-0007, acceptance criteria, and 0 deferred/blocked tasks.
  8. reviews/workflow/mech-goal-sequence-20261019/cycle-000005/stage-06/revision-0001/validation.md:
    • Documents frozen snapshot verification, task-level verification for traitmech-infra-0007, and repository/workflow gate outcomes.
  9. reviews/workflow/mech-goal-sequence-20261019/cycle-000005/stage-06/revision-0001/c5s6_coverage_full.json:
    • Machine-readable coverage summary of all 7 tasks (6 previously resolved, 1 resolved in Cycle 5 Stage 6, 0 remaining open or deferred).
  10. reviews/workflow/mech-goal-sequence-20261019/cycle-000005/stage-06/revision-0001/evidence.yaml:
    • Complete Stage 6 evidence manifest recording source_revision: bc1dfa795cce63059bc4744d06aa371aa335e423, scope_frozen_at: '2026-10-25T23:20:15Z', outcome: completed, all 4 artifacts with SHA-256 digests, infra_tasks disposition for traitmech-infra-0007, and carry_forward_ids: [].

2. Specific Verification Checks

Verification Item Result Evidence
infra_snapshot.md matches supervisor-frozen INFRA_TASKS.md SHA-256 and frozen_at PASS shasum -a 256 .../infra_snapshot.md and git show main:INFRA_TASKS.md | shasum -a 256 both equal 255b181dfdb8d8da5e057b2440b1eb95ba91f7db63f4530ded6144f49770db34; scope_frozen_at: '2026-10-25T23:20:15Z' matches across evidence.yaml, implementation_plan.md, validation.md, and c5s6_coverage_full.json.
reviews/workflow/latest.yaml accurately reflects verified-evidence-index.json (including C5S5 PR #2026) PASS Cycle 5 Stage 5 entry (pr_number: 2026, merge_commit_sha: bc1dfa795cce63059bc4744d06aa371aa335e423, goal_evidence.sha256: 863188fa4de55a257b4d586894822e279ce719d30a3cc416bcbe5d456ac9f618, receipt_sha256: ae17a10a151b8e3e27350a72ffb7cf95127f21f8c4cc3599292a9e431c04fd63) is accurately recorded under authority: verified_closure.
scripts/audit_evidence_snippets.py accurately implements traitmech-infra-0007 (#2002) without regressions PASS corpus_quoted_refs_16 excludes OBJECT_PROPERTY predicate stems, elliptical snippets, and < 16-char snippets; has_corpus_16_quote is gated by not is_object_property and def_source_in_ev, preventing false positives on OBJECT_PROPERTY records or records that do not cite definition_source in evidence[].reference.
Unit tests in tests/test_audit_evidence_snippets.py are complete and sound PASS test_unquoted_definition_source_corpus_wide_16char_quote_when_in_evidence covers < 16-char non-propagation, >= 16-char propagation when def_source_in_ev == True, non-propagation when def_source_in_ev == False, and resolution once a verbatim quote is added.
All SHA-256 digests and paths in evidence.yaml match actual files PASS Verified via shasum -a 256:
- infra_snapshot.md: 255b181dfdb8d8da5e057b2440b1eb95ba91f7db63f4530ded6144f49770db34
- implementation_plan.md: b50ed9b399fc9b8befb94ba1588e065301a0e5b3240d44b2635d8d5634cc9397
- validation.md: 16aad5289044f1e07cb12a2a88f873613b3fe4623d1d0884df988a3b7f11afae
- c5s6_coverage_full.json: 8e0db73f24a5c8bf041ace59514ec4225189a73fcf66a1a0b21ef2e8c9fedeca

3. Findings

  • Findings: None (0 blocking, 0 non-blocking).
  • Final Disposition: approved

@realmarcin
realmarcin added this pull request to the merge queue Oct 26, 2026
Merged via the queue into main with commit 206928d Oct 26, 2026
8 checks passed
@realmarcin
realmarcin deleted the c5s6-infrastructure branch October 26, 2026 00:39
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant