Repository navigation
Conversation
…ation transfer Add a lecture on Green (1982), "Statistical Decision Theory Requiring Incentives for Information Transfer", with the comments by Postlewaite and Riley and the posterior characterization of Blackwell's order by Marschak and Miyasawa (1968). The lecture solves the planner's problem as a linear program, extends Green's two-action theorem to any number of states, gives a complete proof of his result on binomial channels, and checks garblings with a martingale-transport feasibility problem. Exercises cover Riley's example with payments, Postlewaite's four cases, role reversal, and Marschak and Miyasawa's conditions. Place the lecture after blackwell_kihlstrom, add short return links in blackwell_kihlstrom, information_market_equilibrium, pricing_information, opt_transport, and util_rand_resp, and add twelve bibliography entries. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Note
Copilot was unable to complete this review at the selected tier due to model policy or plan restrictions.
🟡 Changes recommended
A moderate correctness issue remains in lectures/information_transfer.md around line 317 where the code can return an inconsistent planner value versus the returned plan Z because planner is not recomputed after x is updated in the ties-handling LP.
1 open issue
What changed in this PR
Adds a new QuantEcon/MyST lecture on Green (1982) and incentive-compatible information transfer, connecting it to the existing information-economics sequence (Blackwell order, information markets, pricing/screening, and optimal transport), and wires it into the book structure with cross-links and citations.
Changes:
- Introduces
lectures/information_transfer.mdwith theory, LP formulations, garbling checks (martingale/transport feasibility), and exercises/solutions. - Updates navigation: inserts the new lecture after
blackwell_kihlstromin_toc.ymland adds short cross-references/return links in related lectures. - Extends
lectures/_static/quant-econ.bibwith the new references cited by the lecture.
Required changes from review comments (moderate):
- In
information_transfer.md(around line 317): whenties != None, recomputeplannerafter updatingx(or keepplanner_optseparately) so the returned objective value matches the returned planZ. - In
information_transfer.md(around line 725): aligngarbling()with the rest of the lecture by disabling HiGHS presolve to avoid false infeasibility on small LP feasibility problems. - In
information_transfer.md(around line 1225): disable HiGHS presolve insolve_with_pay()as well for consistency/robustness with other small LP solves.
| File | Reviewed change |
|---|---|
lectures/util_rand_resp.md |
Adds a brief cross-reference/return link relating informativeness/truthfulness to the new lecture. |
lectures/pricing_information.md |
Adds a short cross-reference contrasting pricing/screening with the information-transfer setting. |
lectures/opt_transport.md |
Adds a short cross-reference noting the transport/feasibility angle used for garbling checks. |
lectures/information_transfer.md |
Adds the new lecture content, code cells, examples, and exercises/solutions (with noted LP-solver consistency items to address). |
lectures/information_market_equilibrium.md |
Adds a short cross-link to the new lecture as a related information-channel model. |
lectures/blackwell_kihlstrom.md |
Adds forward reference/return link positioning the new lecture in the sequence. |
lectures/_toc.yml |
Inserts information_transfer after blackwell_kihlstrom in the book TOC. |
lectures/_static/quant-econ.bib |
Adds the bibliography entries required by the new lecture and references. |
This pull request requires changes.
Review effort: Balanced
A figure caption inside a solution block makes the PDF build fail with "Not in outer par mode", so plot Riley's example as a plain output. Nothing referenced fig-it-riley. Also add the page range to the Holmstrom1984 bibliography entry. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ption Style-guide pass: write the ten displayed matrices with bmatrix rather than pmatrix (qe-math-003), and cut the fig-it-refine caption to five words (qe-fig-004). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
📖 Netlify Preview Ready!Preview URL: https://pr-1119--sunny-cactus-210e3e.netlify.app Commit: 📚 Changed Lectures
Build Info
|
solve_planner and solve_agent_leads already switch presolve off; do the same in garbling and solve_with_pay so all four solves are configured alike. In garbling an infeasibility report is read as "no garbling exists", so a spurious one would give a silently wrong answer. Outputs are unchanged. Addresses Copilot's review overview on this PR. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Addressed Copilot's review.
|
|
thanks @thomassargent30 |
…#50) The nightly refreshes #48 and #49 left the drift check red on two counts; this settles both. The bibliography. QuantEcon/lecture-python.myst#1113 merged intermediate's two entries for Lucas and Prescott (1971) as Lucas_Prescott_1971 and dropped LucasPrescott1971, so the ruling for LucasPrescott1971 in sync/bib.yml, which took intermediate's copy, can no longer apply and tools/bib-merge refused the key. Intro, advanced and jax hold identical copies of the old entry, and no pool lecture cites it since #48, so the ruling is removed rather than replaced: the result is the entry `tools/bib-merge --propose` proposes (take intro, the three seals equal). `tools/bib-merge --write` regenerates lectures/_static/quant-econ.bib, whose LucasPrescott1971 is now the three series' copy, normalised, without the volume, number and DOI that only intermediate's copy had; the key the lectures cite, Lucas_Prescott_1971, keeps them. 906 keys, 56 conflicts, 59 rulings, nothing refused. The toc. QuantEcon/lecture-python.myst#1110 and QuantEcon/lecture-python.myst#1119 added lucas_prescott_search and information_transfer to intermediate's toc, which drift issue #47 reports. `tools/promote --toc intermediate --exclude jax` promotes both, canonical in intermediate with no assets and no rewrites, so the {doc}`information_transfer` references that #49 brought into five pool lectures now resolve. pandas_panel, unchanged in text, records intermediate's current pin, a268b8f, for its second source. `tools/drift-check --accept-toc intermediate` then puts intermediate's _toc.yml under the toc watch at a268b8f, and the README's count of pool lectures follows, from 296 to 298. Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01WT8bMXuHMiWb8victibwcU Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ions (#1121) sphinx-exercise 1.2.2 writes a captioned figure inside an exercise or solution box as `[H]`, as Sphinx does inside its own admonitions, so the PDF build no longer stops with "Not in outer par mode" (executablebooks/sphinx-exercise#94, executablebooks/sphinx-exercise#95). - `environment.yml` and `.github/workflows/collab.yml`: sphinx-exercise 1.2.1 → 1.2.2. - Restores the caption and name on nine figures in gated solutions, removed as the workaround in #1101, #1110 and #1119: exchange_rate_learning (2), genetic_classifier (1), learning_approximation (2), lucas_prescott_search (3), information_transfer (1). Part of QuantEcon/workspace-lectures#70. The workaround is recorded on QuantEcon/meta#297. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

Add a lecture on Green (1982), "Statistical Decision Theory Requiring Incentives for Information Transfer", with the comments by Postlewaite and Riley and the posterior characterization of Blackwell's order by Marschak and Miyasawa (1968).
The lecture solves the planner's problem as a linear program, extends Green's two-action theorem to any number of states, gives a complete proof of his result on binomial channels, and checks garblings with a martingale-transport feasibility problem. Exercises cover Riley's example with payments, Postlewaite's four cases, role reversal, and Marschak and Miyasawa's conditions.
Place the lecture after blackwell_kihlstrom, add short return links in blackwell_kihlstrom, information_market_equilibrium, pricing_information, opt_transport, and util_rand_resp, and add twelve bibliography entries.